• About us
  • Contact us
logotype
Search:
Text
  • Home
  • Primary
  • Secondary
  • Students
  • Library
  • Associates
associates
  • Home
  • Primary
  • Secondary
  • Students
  • Library
  • Associates
  • Sign up
  • Awards
  • Opportunities
  • Experts' Helpline
  • Browse Q & A
  • Newsletter
  • Ambassadors Login
Free resources by e-mail
  • Home>
  • Associates>
  • Browse Q & A>
  • Plasmolysis in beetroot cells

Plasmolysis in beetroot cells

I am planning to investigate plasmolysis in beetroot cells and need two substances to compare in order to perform a t-test. I was thinking of NaCl and CaCl2 but this is too easy as the tri-ion CaCl2 will have a greater attraction for the water and thus increase plasmolysis.

Yes, that sounds "easy", but do both of those compounds ionise to the same extent? Are any other factors coming into play such as carrier molecules in the membranes responding to Ca and Na differently? Biological systems are rarely as simple as we might think.

You can certainly make a prediction, based on sound chemical principles. The real question is whether the material behaves exactly as you have predicted - ie a) do you get a significant difference between Na and Ca chlorides and b) is it in the predicted pattern?

You could include a non-ionic substance like sucrose and compare the effect of similar molarities of NaCl and sucrose to find which molarity causes "incipient plasmolysis" (50% plasmolysis).

Often, the way round a situation like this is to conduct a "trial experiment" to have a quick look and see whether both substances cause plasmolysis and whether the pattern is approximately as you predict. (Don't forget to allow for water of crystalisation in your calculations of molarity.)

John Hewitson

Filter results by type:
Category
Text
  • RSS
  • Share
  • Follow Us
Primary
  • Teaching Resources
  • Beyond the Classroom
  • Hints & Tips
Secondary
  • Teaching Resources
  • Science Clubs
  • Key Themes
  • Biology News
  • Specifications
Students
Library
  • Image Library
  • Links
Legal & Other
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Health and Safety
  • Accessibillity
  • Cookie policy

© 2022 Science & Plants for Schools

Free SAPS newsletter by e-mail

notepad Sign up now